Ethical Shopper

Ethical Shopper

Would lab-grown meat ever be kosher?

Photo by sripfoto/Thinkstock

Photo by sripfoto/Thinkstock


In Genesis, God granted humans dominion over animals. In modern times, that dominion has spawned one of the planet’s biggest threats: a livestock industry that spews greenhouse gases, guzzles resources, and renders the lives of billions of animals brutish and short. Last August, vexed by the problem, a Dutch physiologist named Mark Post came up with a solution: a burger no cow had to die for. He called it the “test-tube burger.”

First, he extracted stem cells from a living cow. Then, he bathed the cells in a nutrient broth and jolted them with electricity, until they multiplied by the billions to form a wall of edible muscle. Post compares the process to cutting off a salamander’s tail and letting it grow back. “It’s letting cells do outside the body what they would otherwise have done inside the body,” he says. 

The result is “biochemically indistinguishable” from cow flesh, he says. “The only difference is we didn’t have to slaughter the cow.” 

Post is not the first to imagine meat divorced from an animal. In 1931, Winston Churchill wrote, “Fifty years hence, we shall escape the absurdity of growing a whole chicken in order to eat the breast or the wing, by growing these parts separately in a suitable medium.” Churchill was close: In the 1990s, science caught up to his vision in the form of bioengineered organs grown from undifferentiated stem cells. By 2000, NASA had shown it was possible to grow fish filets from chunks of fish to feed astronauts on long space flights. 

Yet Post was the first to bioengineer meat that could, conceivably, be widely eaten. This past August, he put his burger to the test at a televised tasting in London, where it was revealed that Google co-founder Sergey Brin had bankrolled the project. Fried in butter and mixed with bread crumbs, the burger was served up to food journalists alongside tomato, lettuce, and a sesame seed bun. The verdict? “This is meat to me,” one declared. 

The event created quite a buzz. Cultured meat, as it is called, captured the imaginations of techies, environmentalists, and animal rights groups—including People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, which, in 2008, offered $1 million to the first person to develop and market a test-tube chicken. In May, a paper in the journal Trends in Biotechnology cited statistics that test-tube meat could reduce land use, water use, and greenhouse gas emissions by more than 95 percent. “Cultured meat,” the authors wrote, “has great moral promise.”

Of course, not everyone is thrilled by the prospect of eating meat grown in a petri dish. A 2014Pew survey found that 80 percent of Americans would be unwilling to try it, and critics caution that test-tube meat needs more testing. The “Frankenburger” might come with hidden health risks, they say, as no country has yet approved it for human consumption. Moreover, at almost $30 per pound, it is prohibitively expensive.

But proponents predict it will turn up on supermarket shelves, eventually. Post hopes to commercialize the burger in five to seven years, while others, including New York–based bioprinting company Modern Meadow, are aiming for sooner. In anticipation, leaders from various religions have already begun investigating whether test-tube meat will fit into their dietary laws. 

For rabbis, the first question is: Is it kosher? Certainly, there are many Jewish legal hurdles test-tube meat would have to clear before a definitive answer could be reached. A central point of debate is the origin of the cells, which some say would have to come from a kosher—that is, cloven-hoofed, cud-chewing—animal. “As a general principle, something derived from a nonkosher animal is not kosher,” says Rabbi Menachem Genack, head of the Orthodox Union’s Kosher Division.

Others, such as Rabbi Carl Feit, chair of the biology department at Yeshiva University, say cultured meat could still be kosher even if the donor animal isn’t. Feit points to the Jewish legal principle of nullification, which states that a trace amount of a forbidden substance can be fully absorbed into an acceptable one without rendering the second treif, or forbidden. If, for example, a piece of meat falls into a glass of milk, the milk is still considered kosher as long as the meat is not more than one-sixtieth of the mixture. 

But for this principle to apply to bioengineered meat, it would have to be shown that cow cells are truly transformed by growing into billions of exact replicas. “Do they ever lose their identity as cow cells?” asks Feit. “At the moment, I’m not convinced they do.”

The next step for rabbis is to determine whether the futuristic foodstuff is meat or something new entirely. Talmudic scholar David Lichtenstein argues the former. Since it has all the physical properties of meat, the test-tube burger “should be assigned all the halachic [Jewish legal] properties of ordinary meat, as well,” he writes in the book Headlines: Halachic Debates of Current Events. The Orthodox Union’s Genack disagrees. He says bioengineered beef is more like milk, which Jewish law considers a derivative of meat but not itself meat. “There’s no principle that says that something that comes out of meat is meat,” he says. Similarly, when science uses cells to make a copy, the result is one step removed from the original substance. Thus Genack concludes that, providing the animal is kosher and properly slaughtered, test-tube meat should be pareve—neither meat nor dairy. This logic opens up the possibility of something magical: a kosher cheeseburger.

Beyond the technicality of test-tube meat’s kosher status are more lofty ethical questions, which have spurred lively debate not only in the Orthodox world but Conservative, Reform, Reconstructionist, and Jewish Renewal circles. Rabbi Moshe Tendler, former chair of the bioethical commission of the Rabbinical Council of America, says the potential new food falls under the Jewish religious mandate to consider innovations that could feed the hungry and prevent animals from being brutally killed. “God gave us a half-finished world and left us to investigate the laws of nature,” he says. “When something comes up that could be of benefit to mankind, it becomes a divine responsibility to do so.” 

Speaking of the almighty, could making meat from cells be considered “playing God”—the culinary equivalent of Jurassic Park? Organic food certifier Rabbi Reuven Flamer thinks it could be. “The idea of mastering life, that which God creates for us in a harmony between foodstuff and the human body, is a slippery slope,” he says. “We don’t know what we’re tinkering with when we make this.”

Judaism is not the only religion grappling with the ramifications of test-tube meat. Playing God may also be a concern for some Muslims, for whom fitra, or God-given naturalness, is a primary value, says Ebrahim Moosa, a professor of Islamic studies at the University of Notre Dame. Making meat in a lab could be interpreted as humans tampering with nature, thus violating fitra. On the other hand, since the purpose of test-tube meat is to preserve the environment—by preventing environmental degradation and allowing more animals to live—it could also be seen as supporting the mandate of naturalness, Moosa says. 

From a Hindu perspective, using an animal’s cells to make meat constitutes an example of human arrogance, says Shaunaka Rishi Das, a Hindu priest and director of the Oxford Centre for Hindu Studies. Rishi Das explains that Hindus—most of whom abstain from meat—do not subscribe to the Western principle of dominion over nonhuman beings. “It’s an entirely different philosophical starting point,” he says. “It’s not: I am the master of you. It is: I am your servant. I am the servant of nature. I am the servant of animals.” Even if the animal is not killed, he says, humans are still asserting that its cells are theirs to use. 

Plus, he points out, the most economical way to feed the world is not with meat but with a vegetarian diet. “It’s not about my need to survive; it’s about my taste buds,” he says.

While they may not eat meat themselves, many Jewish vegetarians say that the bioengineered version could serve as a utilitarian compromise. “Our belief is that anything which will help promote Jewish values of compassion toward animals and preservation of the environment would be a good thing,” says Noam Mohr, vice president of Jewish Vegetarians of North America. “This may be a way of keeping Jewish values for people who still lust for meat.” And many contemporary Jewish spiritual leaders—perhaps following in the footsteps of Abraham Isaac Kook, pre-state Israel’s chief rabbi and a famous vegetarian—are intrigued. “If we had a way to satisfy the physical needs of those who need to eat meat, but could do it in a way that never causes an animal any pain, then certainly that would be a huge spiritual step for Judaism in the spirit of Rabbi Kook,” says Feit, who advocates pursuing the burger with “cautious optimism.” 

Of course, it will take more than optimism to overcome millennia of tradition. The Jewish culture still relies heavily on meat. In fact, the Talmud says: “There is no joy without meat and wine.” It remains to be seen whether Jews will accept what Flamer calls “ersatz flesh” in their brisket and chicken soup. “What blessing would one make over vat-grown meat?” wonders Renewal Rabbi Rachel Barenblat. “Some liturgical creativity might be required.”

This article originally appeared in Moment magazine’s September/October issue. Moment magazine is an independent bimonthly of politics, culture, and religion, co-founded by Nobel Prize laureate Elie Wiesel. For more go to

Rachel E. Gross is a staff writer at Moment who writes often on the intersections between science and culture. Her work has appeared in Wired, New Scientist, and the New York Times.

Source: Slate


Previous article
Next article

Organic Food Is Marketing Hype? - Intelligence Squared Debate

Is the organic movement a hoax? Let us debate.

Don't Eat Anything with a Face? - Intelligence Squared Debate

Taking into account our health, the environment and ethical concerns, which diet is best? A debate.

Ditching in Droves: Why Canadians Are Dropping Milk

It's a good time to be an alternative protein.

Local activists are paying with their life to protect their forests in Peru

Developed world’s greed for hardwood, palm oil, natural gas and beef is killing people on environmental frontiers.

The Solution to Climate Change Isn't Difficult -- It's Delicious

We don't have to relinquish our cars, move to the woods, and get off the grid to conquer climate change. The real solution is simple and easy: eat plants.

New Zealand a World Leader in Animal Welfare

World Animal Protection new global index shows New Zealand a world leader in animal welfare.

Jon Stewart takes on Inhumane Pig Crates on The Daily Show

Tomato Sushi - Sustainable Vegan Tuna

Healthy, meaty sushi without the fish. Tomato Sushi is a natural, eco-friendly alternative to raw tuna, invented by one of America's top chefs.

New Batch of Meat Alternatives Hits the Market

Is Meat Sustainable? Ethiclee Founders discuss in the NZ Herald

Each year, New Zealanders chew their way through three times the world average meat consumption. Is it sustainable, and what are the alternatives?

The Company Leading the Future of Farming

Here's a crazy idea: Combine 3-D printing and tissue engineering to "print" animal products and tackle some of the planet's biggest problems.

NZ feathers are ruffled over dairy free milk

California-based Muufri ruffles Federated Farmers dairy chairman Andrew Hoggard.

Hampton Creek Reinvents the Egg

It doesn't matter whether the chicken or the egg came first. What matters is what comes next.

Last Week Tonight with John Oliver Interviews Dr. Jane Goodall

Two words - 'Poothrow Hitler'.

Milk Grown in a Lab Is Humane and Sustainable. But Can It Catch On?

Time to Decide

Each generation decides what cruelty they will tolerate.

Herbicide and Insecticide Use on GMO Crops Skyrocketing

Rather than reduce pesticide inputs, GMOs are causing them to skyrocket in amount and toxicity.

How to get leather and meat without killing animals

Biofabricating meat and leather is a civilized way to move past killing animals for hamburgers and handbags.

Can Artificial Meat Save The World?

Traditional chicken, beef, and pork production devours resources and creates waste. Meat-free meat might be the solution. 

The Secret of These New Veggie Burgers: Heme

Startup Impossible Foods Seeks to Replicate the Taste of Red Meat Using Plant Matter

Review: 5 Course Vegan Degustation Dinner at Hector's Restaurant

Every year for World Vegetarian Day, Hectors Restaurant holds an event to celebrate plant goodness in style. This year, it was a 5 Course Vegan Degustation Menu.

The ocean's glory — and horror

If we weren't so efficient at catching them, because they grow their entire life, we would have 30-year-old bluefin out there that weigh a ton. (NZ mentioned)

Moby: Animal Agriculture is Killing Us

Animal agriculture is responsible for producing more climate change gases than every car, boat, bus, truck, motorcycle and airplane on the planet. Combined.

Holy Cow

The result is “biochemically indistinguishable” from cow flesh, he says. “The only difference is we didn’t have to slaughter the cow.” 

In Vitro Meat - a Sustainable Compassionate Future

In vitro meat holds the key to a future without factory farming.

Moral Behavior in Animals

Empathy, cooperation, fairness and reciprocity displayed in animals.

Should you stop eating fish?

For most people, eating fish is a choice, not a necessity. Wild fish, like wild birds, have a place in the natural ecosystem which outweighs their value as food.

What's happening to our Oceans

Between 1950 & 2014, Pacific Bluefin Tuna, sharks, and North Atlantic Cod were all almost fished to extinction. Between 5% and 10% remain.

World's first cookbook for lab-grown meat

Mmmm dodo nuggets...

Test-Tube Burgers

How long will it be before you can eat meat that was made in a lab?

The Ethics of Veggie Cats and Dogs

Is it reasonable to expect our pets to forego meat too?

Why I'm a Weekday Vegetarian - TED Talk

We all know the arguments that being vegetarian is better for the environment and for the animals — but in a carnivorous culture, it can be hard to make the...

Billionaire Peter Thiel’s Latest Investment: 3D-Printed Meat

5 Human Feelings that Animals Have Too

Powerful Images of Love & Compassion

Ethiclee featured in Vegan NZ Winter 2014 Issue

The Secrets of Food Marketing

Think you aren't being fooled by advertising tricks? Take a look at this so-called expert revealing food marketing's secret weapon.

Why we drink milk and eat dairy products

Dairy. Why it is bad for you, bad for the planet.

Health Concerns Over GMOs Distract Consumers From the Real Problem Of Monoculture

Corn and soy are monocultural staples with measurable environmental consequences. They are the energy hogging SUVs of the plant world.

Open-source food substitute - is this the beginning of the end of food?

Has a tech entrepreneur come up with a product to replace our meals?

Artificial meat could slice emissions, say scientists

Lab-grown tissue would reduce greenhouse gases by up to 96% in comparison to raising animals.

Save the Bees

How you can save the bees by doing just two things - planting flowers, and buying organic.

Beyond Meat - A Better Way to Feed the Planet

Twitter co-founder Biz Stone explains why he is investing in plant-based meat alternatives.

World's first lab-grown beef hamburger

Google co-founder Sergey Brin explains why he funded the world's first lab-grown beef hamburger.

The Future of Food

Microsoft founder Bill Gates looks at the future of food where we have alternatives to meat that are healthful, tasty and produced more sustainably.

Great Minds on Eating Animals

Thoughts from great minds on eating animals from Einstein to Gandhi to Carl Sagan to Pythagoras to George Bernard Shaw to Tesla.

Famous Celebrity Vegetarians

We will send you an email to reset your password.

or Cancel

Gift Wrapping for $4.50

All gift items are beautifully wrapped in premium recycled matt brown gift wrap with an organic fair trade hemp twine tie before being securely packaged for delivery.